Sensitive & Struggling: Your Eating Disorder Risk Explained

Josie Munroe • March 22, 2024

Understanding the connection between High Sensitivity and disordered eating is crucial.

Being a Highly Sensitive Person (HSP) means your brain is wired to navigate the world in a beautiful and unique way. Many gifts come with this trait, but it can also create some challenges - including an increased risk of developing an eating disorder.


The presentation spectrum of food and body image struggles is extensive, just like the myriad of ways that High Sensitivity presents. Both are unique to the individual but do often show up in a variety of characteristic and behavioral clusters.


While High Sensitivity is a biological trait (Sensory Processing Sensitivity is the scientific name), it is not a diagnosis like an eating disorder. As the name suggests, EDs are multifaceted disorders. You can heal from an eating disorder, but your sensitivity is with you for life. You ARE Highly Sensitive. You have anorexia, bulimia, binge eating disorder, etc.


Becoming familiar with High Sensitivity and how to work WITH your trait is imperative for HSPs.


When I was living with an eating disorder, I didn't know what Sensory Processing Sensitivity was, or that I, myself, am a Highly Sensitive Person. As a therapist, I've specialized in treating food and body image struggles for many years, and I've come to find that many (if not most) of my clients are HSPs too.


Through my work, I've identified 5 reasons why Highly Sensitive People have an increased risk of eating disorders and disordered eating.


1: Sensation Sensitivity


One of the main characteristics of an HSP is a sensitivity to what others find subtle. Sensory information is processed very deeply in the brain, and sensations are often felt to a greater degree. While not all EDs include a disturbance in body image, many do, and this is often heightened in Highly Sensitive People. Subtle changes in body weight or shape may feel intense, which exacerbates disordered thoughts and beliefs.


This sensitivity to sensation also shows up around food. The sensory experiences of eating and the felt sense of hunger and fullness can be quite different and even extreme for HSPs. For example, some textures or smells may be challenging or off-putting, or a shift from a little full to uncomfortably full can happen in seconds.


2: Harm Avoidance


As a temperament trait, harm avoidance may present as chronic worry and doubt, a reluctance to participate in the unfamiliar, and feeling easily fatigued. Studies have shown that the propensity toward avoiding harm is higher in those who develop disordered eating.


Harm avoidance that presents as self-doubt is particularly common among HSPs as their experience in the world has usually been invalidated on countless occasions by statements like, "You're just being too sensitive," or, "It's all in your head."


Highly Sensitive children grow up with this sort of invalidation, even in stable, loving families. It makes sense that we would begin to doubt our own internal cues.


3: Isolation and Secrecy


Not all Highly Sensitive People are isolative introverts, by any means. It's estimated that about 30% of HSPs are extroverts. But what is typically common across the spectrum of sensitivity is the deep need and tendency to withdraw from stimulation for the purpose of sensory rest.


This is normal. However, this healthy alone time may lend itself to the withdrawal that an eating disorder desires.


Eating disorders thrive in isolation and secrecy. When there is a sense of separation and aloneness, a person leans harder on their disordered behaviors, in a way, for a kind of companionship. It is not uncommon for those struggling to feel the conflicting desires to rid themselves of the eating disorder and protect it at all costs.


4: Perfectionism and Comparison


Perfectionism is very common among people with food and body image struggles. This is not always obvious, however, because it can be solely self-oriented, meaning the perfectionist only holds themselves to impossibly high standards, and not others.


Because of the aforementioned Harm Avoidance trait, Highly Sensitive People may mistakenly turn to perfectionism as a protective tactic.


We can believe (on some level) that we might prevent uncomfortable experiences or bad things from happening with the never-ending pursuit of perfection.


Being keenly aware of our environment and the people in it, this tendency toward perfectionism means we're also prone to comparison. Many disordered eating symptoms circle around and our perpetuated by the devastating compulsion of comparing oneself to others.


5: Need for Distraction and Relief


HSPs don't have it easy in this world. We just don't. Especially in Western culture, sensitivity is still seen primarily as a liability - something to be hidden or squashed out of someone. But even when you're in an optimum environment for your sensitivity, it's still tiring to process things so deeply. Wonderful, but tiring.


Enter an eating disorder. They have a remarkable way of blocking out all else and becoming a person's sole focus. Life is whittled down to the pursuit of the ED's desires.


As a survivor, I don't doubt that every single person with an eating disorder history has or had one for very valid reasons. They are coping mechanisms, after all. And they work...until they don't.


Eating disorders are survival techniques that ensnare and baffle. They provide relief and solace but foster challenges and despair at the same time.


Full recovery is possible.


You do not need to become less sensitive to heal. That's a relief, right?


While it's true that High Sensitivity increases your risk of developing an eating disorder, it also gives you the gifts to fully recover from one.


You don't have to go through recovery alone. You were never meant to. 💕



A woman scrolling on her cell phone, looking at news
By Josie Munroe July 11, 2025
Learn how to stay responsibly informed without being overwhelmed. Use these practical, HSP-friendly tips to manage news anxiety and also protect your sanity.
Close-up of a journal listing four New Year's resolutions.
By Josie Munroe December 27, 2024
Move over, rigid resolutions. I've got gentle rituals and practical tips to support your recovery and your sensitivity as you turn over a new calendar page.
Teacher with her head in her hands, appearing overwhelmed in the classroom.
By Josie Munroe December 20, 2024
If you're constantly overwhelmed by feelings of guilt that seem unwarranted or don't ACTUALLY lead to positive change, this simple, effective tool can help.